1
00:00:10,880 --> 00:00:14,015
Mike Rugnetta: Friends, hello,
and welcome to Never Post, a

2
00:00:14,015 --> 00:00:16,415
podcast for and about the
Internet. I'm your host, Mike

3
00:00:16,415 --> 00:00:20,895
Rugnetta, and we have a
resistant show for you this

4
00:00:20,895 --> 00:00:25,640
week. Hans talks with doctor
Casey Fiesler, a professor of

5
00:00:25,640 --> 00:00:29,080
information science at
University of Colorado Boulder,

6
00:00:29,160 --> 00:00:33,320
doctor Alex Hannah, director of
research for the Distributed AI

7
00:00:33,320 --> 00:00:39,000
Research Institute, and numerous
workers from various industries

8
00:00:39,565 --> 00:00:46,045
about being anti AI in the
workplace, but being afraid to

9
00:00:46,045 --> 00:00:50,685
say so or knowing that by saying
so, you may be setting yourself

10
00:00:50,685 --> 00:00:56,060
up for consequences because your
boss has AI psychosis, because

11
00:00:56,060 --> 00:01:00,700
of some vague pronouncement
about the market, because your

12
00:01:00,700 --> 00:01:05,825
coworkers are secretly in love
with a chatbot. But hope is not

13
00:01:05,825 --> 00:01:09,905
lost, Hans learns. It's just a
little hard to see through the

14
00:01:09,905 --> 00:01:11,265
thicket of slop.

15
00:01:11,825 --> 00:01:14,225
First, though, we're gonna take
a quick break. You're gonna

16
00:01:14,225 --> 00:01:17,265
listen to some ads unless you're
on the member feed. And when we

17
00:01:17,265 --> 00:01:21,390
return, Hans, doctor Fiesler,
doctor Hannah, and some of you,

18
00:01:21,390 --> 00:01:27,390
yes, you, our listeners about
being anti AI in the workplace.

19
00:01:42,395 --> 00:01:44,715
Alex Hanna: Alright. I'm going
to share screen. Hopefully, it

20
00:01:44,715 --> 00:01:48,555
all goes apace, and nothing goes
sideways.

21
00:01:50,190 --> 00:01:53,950
Hans Buetow: It's May, and I'm
in a webinar. And it's a really

22
00:01:53,950 --> 00:01:57,390
good webinar. It's about the
launch of the Luddite Lab. So

23
00:01:57,390 --> 00:02:00,990
this is an online hub for
organizing around issues of AI,

24
00:02:00,990 --> 00:02:05,335
and it's run by the fine folks
at DARE, the Distributed AI

25
00:02:05,335 --> 00:02:06,535
Research Institute.

26
00:02:06,535 --> 00:02:08,535
Alex Hanna: DARE or the
Distributed AI Research

27
00:02:08,535 --> 00:02:12,295
Institute is an independent
research organization conducting

28
00:02:12,295 --> 00:02:16,055
community rooted research as a
globally distributed group of

29
00:02:16,055 --> 00:02:18,775
academics, activists, and
engineers who believe in

30
00:02:18,775 --> 00:02:20,990
technology that benefits
everyone.

31
00:02:21,070 --> 00:02:25,390
Hans Buetow: I'm in this webinar
because DARE is awesome. And

32
00:02:25,390 --> 00:02:29,150
this project and this webinar,
they've got the word Luddite in

33
00:02:29,150 --> 00:02:33,390
the title, which is one of my
self selected beats on Never

34
00:02:33,390 --> 00:02:37,845
Post. So I'm here. I'm drinking
tea. I'm snacking on snacks,

35
00:02:37,925 --> 00:02:41,205
sesame sticks by the way, which
my grandma called cat food and

36
00:02:41,205 --> 00:02:43,605
fed me an awful lot of when I
was little.

37
00:02:44,645 --> 00:02:48,325
Suddenly, get a little slack
ping from our host Mike Ragneta.

38
00:02:48,850 --> 00:02:52,370
Mike Rugnetta: I wonder if
there's a segment to be had in

39
00:02:52,370 --> 00:02:57,250
looking at employees who are
anti AI, but they're afraid to

40
00:02:57,250 --> 00:03:01,330
say anything because of the
position that their employer

41
00:03:01,330 --> 00:03:01,730
takes.

42
00:03:03,235 --> 00:03:06,595
Hans Buetow: I pause mid sip of
tea, cat food just hanging out

43
00:03:06,595 --> 00:03:10,755
of my mouth, because on my other
screen, webinar chat is burning

44
00:03:10,755 --> 00:03:11,235
up.

45
00:03:11,235 --> 00:03:16,115
Speaker 4: This is extremely
timely for me. My workplace and

46
00:03:16,115 --> 00:03:21,040
academic library, yeah, we
should know better, is going all

47
00:03:21,040 --> 00:03:24,960
in on AI, and nobody will
promise me that I'm allowed to

48
00:03:24,960 --> 00:03:25,680
opt out.

49
00:03:26,560 --> 00:03:28,400
Hans Buetow: There are a bunch
of librarians in the chat

50
00:03:28,400 --> 00:03:31,120
actually finding each other,
finding other people who aren't

51
00:03:31,120 --> 00:03:31,760
librarians.

52
00:03:32,245 --> 00:03:34,805
Speaker 5: Wow. I work at a
Fortune 500 company, and I

53
00:03:34,805 --> 00:03:37,925
thought the AI Kool Aid was
limited to the corporate world.

54
00:03:38,005 --> 00:03:43,125
Very worrying that academia
education is embracing this

55
00:03:43,125 --> 00:03:43,925
madness.

56
00:03:45,205 --> 00:03:48,210
Hans Buetow: The messages are
collecting fast and furious

57
00:03:48,210 --> 00:03:51,890
about people feeling alienated
by AI in their workplace, and so

58
00:03:51,890 --> 00:03:55,570
I spit out the cat food from my
mouth. I slap on my Jordy

59
00:03:55,570 --> 00:03:59,650
Laforte shades and my fingerless
gloves and slam on the all caps.

60
00:04:00,850 --> 00:04:10,175
This is exactly the webinar I'm
in. Sip a tea, cat food. Oh, num

61
00:04:10,175 --> 00:04:10,735
num.

62
00:04:12,255 --> 00:04:14,975
Mike Rugnetta: Okay. So the
answer is yes.

63
00:04:18,790 --> 00:04:21,030
Hans Buetow: I sat there
watching the chat some more, and

64
00:04:21,190 --> 00:04:24,950
I suddenly had this weird sense
memory of being at work during

65
00:04:24,950 --> 00:04:28,230
the pandemic and watching the
Slack chat during a staff

66
00:04:28,230 --> 00:04:31,995
meeting while they were
discussing masking or work from

67
00:04:31,995 --> 00:04:35,915
home, and watching people
furiously on main and then also

68
00:04:35,915 --> 00:04:39,675
in side channels debating the
biggest changes in our working

69
00:04:39,675 --> 00:04:45,250
lives in probably a generation.
And then I remember after a

70
00:04:45,250 --> 00:04:48,850
while, those conversations just
went away. Not that there

71
00:04:48,850 --> 00:04:51,570
weren't people resistant to
taking off masks or coming back

72
00:04:51,570 --> 00:04:55,090
to the office, just that more
and more each day, it seemed,

73
00:04:55,570 --> 00:05:00,395
everyone was just doing it. The
world was changing around us and

74
00:05:00,395 --> 00:05:04,955
that shifted the context that
turned our norms into

75
00:05:04,955 --> 00:05:09,515
convictions. So, yes, lol.

76
00:05:09,960 --> 00:05:13,400
It's too simple, I think to
myself, as I swap out my Men in

77
00:05:13,400 --> 00:05:17,880
Black Predator two Ray Bans.
Sling on my Faraday gun bag and

78
00:05:17,880 --> 00:05:21,320
crack my knuckles, accepting
that I need to do a Never Post

79
00:05:21,320 --> 00:05:26,775
story about this. Too simple.
You know it's too simple. Mike

80
00:05:26,775 --> 00:05:27,975
knows it's too simple.

81
00:05:28,455 --> 00:05:31,175
Mike Rugnetta: I don't know. I'd
wanna get some input from folks

82
00:05:31,175 --> 00:05:33,095
who feel this way too.

83
00:05:33,415 --> 00:05:35,975
Hans Buetow: Let's do it.
Because in this episode, I want

84
00:05:35,975 --> 00:05:40,215
to better understand the nuances
of why it can feel just so

85
00:05:40,215 --> 00:05:46,690
difficult to be an AI refuser at
work. So, first step, do folks

86
00:05:46,850 --> 00:05:50,290
actually feel uncomfortable
about AI in their workplaces?

87
00:05:50,690 --> 00:05:54,130
So, where to look? Easy.

88
00:05:54,370 --> 00:05:58,565
Did you know we have a Never
Post subreddit? R slash never

89
00:05:58,565 --> 00:06:07,525
post. Do you have a story about
a moment where AI was brought

90
00:06:07,525 --> 00:06:11,800
into your workflow by a
colleague, either mandated by

91
00:06:11,800 --> 00:06:21,560
the organization or not, and you
had to reckon with it. Turns out

92
00:06:21,560 --> 00:06:24,840
people really wanna talk about
AI at their workplace.

93
00:06:24,840 --> 00:06:25,535
Jazzy Minotaur: Hey, Never Post.

94
00:06:25,535 --> 00:06:26,015
Speaker 4: Hey, Never Post.

95
00:06:26,015 --> 00:06:26,655
Mike Rugnetta: Hi, Never Post.

96
00:06:26,815 --> 00:06:28,895
Talia: I saw the request on
Reddit for awkward AI

97
00:06:28,895 --> 00:06:30,175
interactions at work.

98
00:06:30,735 --> 00:06:33,215
Hans Buetow: So I'm gonna put
your responses into two

99
00:06:33,215 --> 00:06:37,135
categories. The first was people
watching their coworkers and

100
00:06:37,135 --> 00:06:40,495
their customers normalizing the
use of AI in a work setting.

101
00:06:40,780 --> 00:06:44,060
Speaker 8: One of my coworkers
has gone all in on it. I found

102
00:06:44,060 --> 00:06:47,260
him putting in basic math
problems into it instead of just

103
00:06:47,260 --> 00:06:51,340
opening the calculator program.
It has replaced most any

104
00:06:51,340 --> 00:06:52,540
critical thought in his life.

105
00:06:53,205 --> 00:06:53,685
Speaker 5: I was

106
00:06:53,685 --> 00:06:56,565
Talia: asked to copyedit some
text for a coworker. When I

107
00:06:56,565 --> 00:07:01,445
returned it, they said, thanks,
Chatchipitalia, which I hope and

108
00:07:01,445 --> 00:07:04,965
believe, that they said with the
intention of being polite, but

109
00:07:04,965 --> 00:07:09,250
it most certainly made me feel
deeply patronized or maybe like

110
00:07:09,250 --> 00:07:13,970
objectified. Used beyond the
regular scope of my labor for

111
00:07:13,970 --> 00:07:16,210
sure. Deeply grossed me out.

112
00:07:16,290 --> 00:07:21,250
Speaker 9: I work at an arcade
and I have seen AI touching the

113
00:07:21,250 --> 00:07:24,945
Jersey Jack pinball table based
off of the Harry Potter license.

114
00:07:25,665 --> 00:07:31,025
This table had its artwork done
by an artist who uses AI tools

115
00:07:31,025 --> 00:07:34,865
in their process. Public
reception as I've talked with

116
00:07:34,865 --> 00:07:42,120
other pinball players has been
that they do not care about the

117
00:07:42,120 --> 00:07:47,720
artwork being AI generated. All
that matters is how the game

118
00:07:47,720 --> 00:07:51,720
plays, and that is bizarre to
me.

119
00:07:56,265 --> 00:07:58,185
Hans Buetow: A lot of the
responses in this category were

120
00:07:58,185 --> 00:08:02,665
about people in parallel roles,
so peers and colleagues. The

121
00:08:02,665 --> 00:08:05,145
responses that involved
supervisors or a whole

122
00:08:05,145 --> 00:08:08,910
organization, those tended to
fall into the other category of

123
00:08:08,910 --> 00:08:13,470
responses, which felt a lot more
existential.

124
00:08:14,910 --> 00:08:18,430
Speaker 5: I work in health care
IT. It feels wretched to have no

125
00:08:18,430 --> 00:08:21,150
leverage to say no to something
that's definitely gonna cause

126
00:08:21,150 --> 00:08:23,775
potentially lethal problems down
the road.

127
00:08:24,095 --> 00:08:27,375
Speaker 10: For about ten years,
was instructor in English,

128
00:08:27,375 --> 00:08:31,055
college English courses
specifically. When I pushed back

129
00:08:31,055 --> 00:08:37,330
against kind of this AI embrace,
they told me that they were

130
00:08:37,330 --> 00:08:42,690
bored reading the same kind of
wrote paper students wrote, so I

131
00:08:42,690 --> 00:08:46,210
don't really care if they use
AI. I mean, that's hard to,

132
00:08:46,210 --> 00:08:48,705
like, hear. I think we should
have pride in what we do as

133
00:08:48,705 --> 00:08:51,985
educators and like, even if we
get bored reading the same like

134
00:08:51,985 --> 00:08:55,665
five business letters over and
over again, that's our job.

135
00:08:55,665 --> 00:08:56,305
Right?

136
00:08:56,465 --> 00:08:59,585
Speaker 5: I work in reality TV
and documentary post production.

137
00:09:00,380 --> 00:09:05,740
I have a strong moral objection
to using it myself, but when I'm

138
00:09:05,740 --> 00:09:08,780
part of a team that decides to
go down an ethically dubious

139
00:09:08,780 --> 00:09:13,500
route as a majority or at the
behest of a particularly AI

140
00:09:13,500 --> 00:09:17,215
obsessed showrunner, it's a very
uncomfortable feeling. I mean,

141
00:09:17,215 --> 00:09:21,375
the nature of my role is such
that, like, often the actual

142
00:09:21,375 --> 00:09:25,455
generation of these elements
falls on me. Hey. Can you create

143
00:09:25,455 --> 00:09:28,255
a clone of Daniel's voice so we
can have him say that he's doing

144
00:09:28,255 --> 00:09:29,375
x for y reasons?

145
00:09:29,910 --> 00:09:33,190
In the past six months, many
network AI standards have become

146
00:09:33,190 --> 00:09:35,110
markedly more lenient.

147
00:09:36,710 --> 00:09:40,550
Speaker 11: In the last three or
four months, IT leadership has

148
00:09:40,550 --> 00:09:49,595
been reframing us from software
developers to AI engineers. I

149
00:09:50,075 --> 00:09:54,955
don't think I really have any
fear of losing my job to AI at

150
00:09:54,955 --> 00:10:01,130
this point, but I am very fairly
confident that this AI engineer

151
00:10:01,130 --> 00:10:05,130
path is going to be what the
future of my career looks like.

152
00:10:05,450 --> 00:10:06,650
It's been exhausting.

153
00:10:09,095 --> 00:10:15,095
Hans Buetow: So with risk to
reputation, risk to jobs, is it

154
00:10:15,095 --> 00:10:19,255
really any wonder that some
people don't feel the space to

155
00:10:19,255 --> 00:10:21,495
be able to be viewed
professionally as critical or

156
00:10:21,495 --> 00:10:32,470
resistant to new technologies? I
mean, precarity meet judgment. I

157
00:10:32,470 --> 00:10:35,830
really started to understand
what it meant to be wary of AI

158
00:10:35,830 --> 00:10:39,815
while under pro AI scrutiny when
I read a post from Jazzy

159
00:10:39,815 --> 00:10:45,015
Minotaur who wrote, my VP of IT
had a meeting where we could all

160
00:10:45,015 --> 00:10:49,095
share our thoughts before major
AI policy decisions got made. He

161
00:10:49,095 --> 00:10:52,295
pretty much ignored every
negative statement and acted

162
00:10:52,295 --> 00:10:57,390
like he only heard supportive
statements. Jazzy Minatar agreed

163
00:10:57,390 --> 00:11:01,950
to talk with me, but only
anonymously, which is, I wanna

164
00:11:01,950 --> 00:11:05,950
say, notably, how most people
responded.

165
00:11:06,350 --> 00:11:10,430
Jazzy Minotaur: It was a meeting
because our company didn't have

166
00:11:10,955 --> 00:11:16,315
an AI policy. So anyone using AI
was more or less violating

167
00:11:16,315 --> 00:11:21,435
company policy. None of us
wanted to be viewed as negative

168
00:11:21,435 --> 00:11:26,070
on a technology. It makes us
seem like the old guy who's

169
00:11:26,070 --> 00:11:29,430
can't use an iPhone, you know,
because they just aren't

170
00:11:29,430 --> 00:11:32,470
adapting to new technology. So
all of us wanted to seem like

171
00:11:32,470 --> 00:11:37,195
there were a lot of positives
with some negatives, But it

172
00:11:37,195 --> 00:11:40,315
really became kind of clear that
the negatives were just gonna

173
00:11:40,315 --> 00:11:43,435
get ignored no matter what we
brought up.

174
00:11:44,235 --> 00:11:47,515
Hans Buetow: What is the risk to
you if you get labeled that way?

175
00:11:48,330 --> 00:11:51,850
Jazzy Minotaur: If you get
labeled that way, then you are

176
00:11:51,850 --> 00:11:57,770
probably viewed as only as
efficient as you are the last

177
00:11:57,770 --> 00:12:04,435
time you started updating. So
you are only as useful as the

178
00:12:04,915 --> 00:12:06,915
newest technology you've
learned.

179
00:12:08,515 --> 00:12:11,235
Hans Buetow: Look. I know that
technology changes super fast

180
00:12:11,235 --> 00:12:13,715
and that folks need to be
certified. They need to be up to

181
00:12:13,715 --> 00:12:17,510
speed. And I also know that the
tech industry is funded by toxic

182
00:12:17,510 --> 00:12:21,670
optimists. But if I were in
charge, which I dare you

183
00:12:21,670 --> 00:12:22,470
cowards.

184
00:12:23,030 --> 00:12:26,950
But if I were in charge, I think
I'd also value that perspective

185
00:12:26,950 --> 00:12:31,705
that, hey. Maybe we should apply
some critical rigor to this new

186
00:12:31,705 --> 00:12:35,065
technology that seems to have
some real risks and drawbacks.

187
00:12:36,185 --> 00:12:39,385
But that's not how the tech
industry works or at least how

188
00:12:39,385 --> 00:12:41,545
the industry part of the tech
industry works.

189
00:12:42,260 --> 00:12:48,020
Jazzy Minotaur: I think there is
a drive to bring costs down, and

190
00:12:48,020 --> 00:12:50,980
the marketing is nothing but,
hey, this will bring your costs

191
00:12:50,980 --> 00:12:57,925
down. And any skepticism towards
that is more just, kind of being

192
00:12:57,925 --> 00:13:00,005
against the company doing
better.

193
00:13:02,165 --> 00:13:04,405
Hans Buetow: In the modern
hierarchy of needs, it goes

194
00:13:04,405 --> 00:13:11,870
number one, company, end of
list. Hang on a sec. Have to put

195
00:13:11,870 --> 00:13:17,870
on my monocle to read this. Next
one. This fear of judgement?

196
00:13:17,870 --> 00:13:24,015
This is everywhere in AI. Women
are 25% less likely to use AI.

197
00:13:24,415 --> 00:13:29,215
Why? Well, a recent paper from
Harvard Business School asked

198
00:13:29,215 --> 00:13:32,975
that question, and women cited
this fear of judgment that if

199
00:13:32,975 --> 00:13:35,535
they were to use AI, they'd be
seen as dummies who need a

200
00:13:35,535 --> 00:13:39,670
computer crutch to solve even
basic problems. But their male

201
00:13:39,670 --> 00:13:44,550
counterparts are seen as bold,
as mavericks, as ingenious for

202
00:13:44,550 --> 00:13:45,590
using AI.

203
00:13:46,230 --> 00:13:51,035
And then there's the terror of
your work being judged. AI

204
00:13:51,035 --> 00:13:56,555
allows you to suddenly sidestep
that fear. Have an LLM do it?

205
00:13:56,555 --> 00:14:00,955
You have someone to blame when
it goes tits up. This was summed

206
00:14:00,955 --> 00:14:02,795
up for me by our listener Talia.

207
00:14:02,955 --> 00:14:06,395
Talia: There seems to be a
throughline of AI use at work

208
00:14:06,450 --> 00:14:09,490
being about decreasing
vulnerability, like minimizing

209
00:14:09,490 --> 00:14:13,250
the attack surface. Terror at
the judgment of their

210
00:14:13,250 --> 00:14:17,090
professional outputs seems to
drive people into the arms of AI

211
00:14:17,730 --> 00:14:23,965
while predictably pummeling
their capacity further. I want

212
00:14:23,965 --> 00:14:27,485
my coworkers to know that their
work is good, that their

213
00:14:27,485 --> 00:14:31,325
thinking on a matter is
valuable, that their labor is

214
00:14:31,325 --> 00:14:32,525
deserving of respect.

215
00:14:38,320 --> 00:14:42,080
Hans Buetow: The scope and power
of this fear of judgment really

216
00:14:42,080 --> 00:14:46,605
hit me when Jazzy Minatar
described their attitude during

217
00:14:46,605 --> 00:14:48,925
that meeting that they were
having with their bosses.

218
00:14:48,925 --> 00:14:52,685
Jazzy Minotaur: Most of us were
trying to be balanced going in.

219
00:14:53,805 --> 00:14:57,405
We, you know, have to look at
them objectively even if we have

220
00:14:57,405 --> 00:15:01,690
a moral objection to AI. We have
to look at it from a company's

221
00:15:01,690 --> 00:15:02,410
perspective.

222
00:15:03,370 --> 00:15:06,330
Hans Buetow: At this point, I
whipped off my specs, narrowed

223
00:15:06,330 --> 00:15:10,250
my eyes, lit my desk on fire,
and stared Jazzy Minotaur

224
00:15:10,250 --> 00:15:13,370
directly in the black square
that was their turned off video.

225
00:15:14,015 --> 00:15:17,455
Those are two powerful words
that are not gonna slip by me.

226
00:15:18,175 --> 00:15:21,535
Why? Why do you need, if you
have a moral objection to

227
00:15:21,535 --> 00:15:25,615
something, to put that aside and
look at it from the company's

228
00:15:25,615 --> 00:15:26,255
perspective?

229
00:15:27,375 --> 00:15:31,990
Jazzy Minotaur: At one point, it
was expected that a person who

230
00:15:31,990 --> 00:15:35,590
worked for a company would
utilize their own ethics, their

231
00:15:35,590 --> 00:15:35,830
Alex Hanna: own

232
00:15:35,830 --> 00:15:39,830
Jazzy Minotaur: morals, and
utilize those in decision

233
00:15:39,830 --> 00:15:44,605
making. Today, though, we more
or less are bowing to a

234
00:15:44,605 --> 00:15:50,285
fiduciary responsibility to
shareholders, and anything we

235
00:15:50,285 --> 00:15:57,110
could do that would increase
their value is more or less a

236
00:15:57,110 --> 00:16:00,310
legal obligation for the
company. When I'm acting as a

237
00:16:00,310 --> 00:16:03,750
human, as a person, I'm allowed
my morals. I'm allowed my

238
00:16:03,750 --> 00:16:09,350
values, my ethics. When I'm
acting as a company, I'm no

239
00:16:09,350 --> 00:16:10,550
longer allowed those things.

240
00:16:14,175 --> 00:16:19,215
Hans Buetow: I get it. I get it.
I get it. But it also feels way

241
00:16:19,215 --> 00:16:24,175
more bleak than I'm willing to
accept. I can't really get over

242
00:16:24,175 --> 00:16:29,030
this idea that companies are us,
and we are companies.

243
00:16:29,030 --> 00:16:33,110
It's like Citizens United, but,
like, the other way around, and

244
00:16:33,190 --> 00:16:39,830
that sucks too. So how do you be
a moral person? How do you stand

245
00:16:39,830 --> 00:16:44,755
against it, especially with
management out there ready to

246
00:16:44,755 --> 00:16:48,915
replace me with anyone else?
Ideally, from their perspective,

247
00:16:49,235 --> 00:16:50,835
with an AI agent.

248
00:16:53,795 --> 00:16:57,555
Casey Fiesler: So obviously,
social norms play a huge role

249
00:16:57,555 --> 00:17:04,620
here. And I think that we don't
yet have very strong social

250
00:17:04,620 --> 00:17:07,500
norms around some of these
things yet. And when we're in

251
00:17:07,500 --> 00:17:10,300
this position where they're sort
of in the process of being

252
00:17:10,300 --> 00:17:13,260
formed, that's a really tricky
place.

253
00:17:14,615 --> 00:17:16,535
Hans Buetow: This is doctor
Casey Fiesler.

254
00:17:16,535 --> 00:17:20,695
Casey Fiesler: I'm doctor Casey
Fiesler. I'm a professor of

255
00:17:20,695 --> 00:17:23,815
information science at
University of Colorado Boulder.

256
00:17:24,295 --> 00:17:27,575
Hans Buetow: I needed Casey's
help with those two words, moral

257
00:17:27,575 --> 00:17:31,810
objection, and how they
intersect with capitalism.

258
00:17:32,130 --> 00:17:38,130
Casey Fiesler: The choice
becomes between your morals and

259
00:17:38,130 --> 00:17:43,570
being able to pay your rent.
Olivia, it's a ton of pressure

260
00:17:43,570 --> 00:17:46,505
because you might get fired if
you don't use it, and that's the

261
00:17:46,505 --> 00:17:49,705
kind of thing that absolutely
can override moral objections.

262
00:17:50,825 --> 00:17:53,785
Hans Buetow: I wanna be super
clear. I get it. I've done it

263
00:17:53,785 --> 00:17:58,600
often. And I will never judge
someone for being forced to make

264
00:17:58,600 --> 00:18:01,400
that bargain from inside of a
system. Never.

265
00:18:02,760 --> 00:18:06,520
But this is a heartbreaking
reminder that surviving

266
00:18:06,520 --> 00:18:10,680
capitalism is in a way its own
moral obligation. I need to

267
00:18:10,680 --> 00:18:15,045
live. You need to live. And
since our being alive is so

268
00:18:15,045 --> 00:18:19,525
dependent on our jobs, in our
current system, it can come down

269
00:18:19,525 --> 00:18:22,005
to you versus me.

270
00:18:22,165 --> 00:18:25,045
Casey Fiesler: Suddenly, you're
being pitted against other other

271
00:18:25,045 --> 00:18:25,525
people.

272
00:18:26,390 --> 00:18:30,070
Hans Buetow: AI is now a them in
the middle of this fight, a new

273
00:18:30,070 --> 00:18:33,510
combatant for the same jobs, and
it's backed by these huge

274
00:18:33,510 --> 00:18:36,710
corporations that are talked
about as being completely

275
00:18:36,710 --> 00:18:39,830
synonymous with the future of
the entire US economy.

276
00:18:40,855 --> 00:18:43,815
Casey Fiesler: So I do think
that there's some push that

277
00:18:43,815 --> 00:18:47,335
like, how do you get people to
use your product? One of them

278
00:18:47,335 --> 00:18:52,455
is, oh my god, you're gonna get
left behind and you're, you

279
00:18:52,455 --> 00:18:56,280
know, everyone else is gonna be
like passing you, you're not

280
00:18:56,280 --> 00:19:01,160
going be able to get a job, and
you're hearing this from

281
00:19:01,320 --> 00:19:05,400
students too, like I I I hear
from students constantly who

282
00:19:05,400 --> 00:19:09,615
tell me that they think that
professors should never ban AI

283
00:19:09,615 --> 00:19:14,335
because they all need to be
using AI constantly because they

284
00:19:14,335 --> 00:19:19,215
think they can't get a job if
they aren't like good at using

285
00:19:19,215 --> 00:19:22,335
AI and therefore should, you
know, practice it at every

286
00:19:22,335 --> 00:19:22,815
opportunity.

287
00:19:27,990 --> 00:19:30,790
Hans Buetow: I had wanted to
talk to Casey because of a video

288
00:19:30,790 --> 00:19:33,990
that she had posted about this
very thing, about student use of

289
00:19:33,990 --> 00:19:34,630
AI.

290
00:19:34,710 --> 00:19:36,070
Casey Fiesler: Because an
interesting thing about the

291
00:19:36,070 --> 00:19:39,005
proliferation of generative AI
is that it hasn't just created

292
00:19:39,005 --> 00:19:42,045
the ability to cheat, it has
created incentives to cheat.

293
00:19:42,845 --> 00:19:45,885
Hans Buetow: Incentives.
Incentive to do something they

294
00:19:45,885 --> 00:19:49,725
know is bad for them. To use a
tool that according to a Brown

295
00:19:49,725 --> 00:19:52,180
University survey of their
students, around eighty eight

296
00:19:52,180 --> 00:19:55,620
percent of undergraduates fear
is affecting their learning and

297
00:19:55,620 --> 00:19:56,980
cognitive capacity.

298
00:19:56,980 --> 00:19:59,940
Casey Fiesler: People often use
AI in learning context not

299
00:19:59,940 --> 00:20:02,100
because they think that it's
good for them, but because they

300
00:20:02,100 --> 00:20:05,860
assume everyone else is using
it. And if they don't, they will

301
00:20:05,860 --> 00:20:06,740
be at a disadvantage.

302
00:20:08,285 --> 00:20:11,005
Hans Buetow: Students start to
assume that probably everybody

303
00:20:11,005 --> 00:20:14,445
else is just already in these
streets, just way ahead of them,

304
00:20:14,445 --> 00:20:17,485
practicing AI every day. I don't
know, whatever that means. The

305
00:20:17,485 --> 00:20:21,870
fear of judgment is just rocket
fueled by the mystery of who's

306
00:20:21,870 --> 00:20:26,670
using it and who's not.
Famously, saying to a young

307
00:20:26,670 --> 00:20:32,030
person, hey. Everyone's doing it
over and over and over again has

308
00:20:32,030 --> 00:20:32,990
consequences.

309
00:20:33,790 --> 00:20:37,365
Just this morning, I turned on
the radio, and there was Bernie

310
00:20:37,365 --> 00:20:39,285
Sanders yelling at me.

311
00:20:39,285 --> 00:20:43,685
Bernie Sanders: We are already
starting to see AI's impact.

312
00:20:44,325 --> 00:20:49,205
There are estimates from very
credible sources that tens of

313
00:20:49,205 --> 00:20:54,340
millions of jobs could be lost
here in The United States in the

314
00:20:54,340 --> 00:20:59,540
next ten years. Whole
professions wiped out and young

315
00:20:59,540 --> 00:21:05,380
people finding it harder and
harder to land entry level jobs.

316
00:21:06,295 --> 00:21:09,575
Hans Buetow: Yeah. There are
boogeymen everywhere. Look at

317
00:21:09,575 --> 00:21:12,215
these influencers and companies,
and they're all adapting the

318
00:21:12,215 --> 00:21:15,095
tools. Look at over there. How
many other people are going

319
00:21:15,095 --> 00:21:17,015
after this job or scholarship?

320
00:21:17,255 --> 00:21:21,720
Look at all these articles about
how many students are cheating

321
00:21:21,720 --> 00:21:27,080
with AI. Maybe maybe I'm the
only one stewing about this, and

322
00:21:27,080 --> 00:21:30,680
I need to cheat too. It's out of
my hands.

323
00:21:31,160 --> 00:21:37,005
Casey Fiesler: Regardless of how
you might feel about AI morally

324
00:21:37,085 --> 00:21:40,525
or self interested concerns
about your own learning or

325
00:21:40,525 --> 00:21:43,165
cognitive impact, you might use
it anyway.

326
00:21:43,565 --> 00:21:47,850
Hans Buetow: Suspicions are high
that they are behind already. So

327
00:21:47,850 --> 00:21:52,170
are we surprised that when you
hold students jobs prospects

328
00:21:52,170 --> 00:22:02,465
ransom, they're gonna do what
you say? So what are workers, us

329
00:22:02,465 --> 00:22:06,945
in any sector, what are we
supposed to do against that same

330
00:22:06,945 --> 00:22:10,705
onslaught of messaging? If you
are someone who is against AI,

331
00:22:10,945 --> 00:22:15,050
but you're feeling all this
pressure and judgment, is there

332
00:22:15,050 --> 00:22:17,610
another way to approach it?

333
00:22:19,050 --> 00:22:26,490
Casey Fiesler: I do think that
there is some level of knowledge

334
00:22:27,315 --> 00:22:34,435
of AI and how it works that will
help you use it better, like

335
00:22:34,435 --> 00:22:40,195
more responsibly, and if you're
the person at your workplace who

336
00:22:40,195 --> 00:22:47,040
can explain to people why
hallucinations happen, why this

337
00:22:47,040 --> 00:22:51,840
needs to be double checked, and
different ways that you might

338
00:22:51,840 --> 00:22:56,240
think about using the technology
that isn't going to get as much

339
00:22:56,240 --> 00:23:00,865
backlash. There is a level of
knowledge of AI especially in

340
00:23:00,865 --> 00:23:05,345
terms of responsible AI use that
could actually be of help in a

341
00:23:05,345 --> 00:23:09,905
in a company, and if you're
having, you know, moral concerns

342
00:23:09,905 --> 00:23:17,390
about AI use, but there really
is pressure for you to show some

343
00:23:17,390 --> 00:23:21,230
level of competence in AI or
some level of use of it, then

344
00:23:21,230 --> 00:23:26,245
maybe that's the direction to
think about. Can you be a voice

345
00:23:26,245 --> 00:23:31,685
of reason? At least using AI
responsibly if you're gonna have

346
00:23:31,685 --> 00:23:37,765
to use it. So maybe that maybe
that's a value add.

347
00:23:39,820 --> 00:23:43,420
That's my anyway, if I if I had
to have a little, glimmer of

348
00:23:43,420 --> 00:23:44,780
hope, silver lining.

349
00:23:48,300 --> 00:23:50,620
Hans Buetow: I appreciate
Casey's optimism, trying to

350
00:23:50,620 --> 00:23:54,300
balance moral obligation with a
work obligation, and it's hard.

351
00:23:54,765 --> 00:23:59,805
It's hard. But I wanna talk to
somebody who's maybe trying to

352
00:23:59,805 --> 00:24:04,445
do that. So as I say my goodbyes
to Casey, I'm thinking, oh, boy.

353
00:24:05,005 --> 00:24:08,205
That feels like the kind of
person who would be willing to

354
00:24:08,205 --> 00:24:12,620
use their name, who'd be willing
to go on record, be vocal about

355
00:24:12,620 --> 00:24:13,660
this with me.

356
00:24:13,660 --> 00:24:18,140
Someone who, when confronted
with an AI assignment from their

357
00:24:18,140 --> 00:24:20,460
bosses, might say, I don't know,
something like

358
00:24:20,860 --> 00:24:22,700
Liana: You're gonna have
employees who don't know how to

359
00:24:22,700 --> 00:24:27,395
do x, y, or z anymore if you
outsource it to some agent or

360
00:24:27,395 --> 00:24:31,475
subscript. Right? Are you
comfortable with that?

361
00:24:33,235 --> 00:24:35,475
Hans Buetow: I gotta head to the
van. I'm gonna grab my Velma

362
00:24:35,475 --> 00:25:09,025
glasses for this one, so let's
take a quick break. My job had

363
00:25:09,025 --> 00:25:13,790
been to find someone who was
owning their AI refusal at work,

364
00:25:13,790 --> 00:25:17,870
doing what they can to develop
and progress norms around AI in

365
00:25:17,870 --> 00:25:24,670
their workplace. Amazingly, I
found someone. Someone who

366
00:25:24,670 --> 00:25:29,155
referred to themselves as well
known as the AI hater in their

367
00:25:29,155 --> 00:25:33,635
office, which, like Jazzy
Minotaur, was a tech office.

368
00:25:33,635 --> 00:25:35,395
Liana: I'm in the video game
industry.

369
00:25:35,555 --> 00:25:39,475
Hans Buetow: This is Liana who
was unique among respondents

370
00:25:39,475 --> 00:25:43,520
because she allowed me to use
her actual factual name. Liana

371
00:25:43,520 --> 00:25:48,800
is opposed to AI. And like Casey
suggested, she's trying to help

372
00:25:48,800 --> 00:25:52,560
the folks around her to better
understand the tools that are

373
00:25:52,560 --> 00:25:53,600
available to them.

374
00:25:54,000 --> 00:25:57,605
Liana: I do my best to bring up
the practical. I try my best to

375
00:25:57,605 --> 00:26:00,005
make the quote unquote business
case. Right?

376
00:26:00,325 --> 00:26:05,365
Hans Buetow: So one day, Liana's
in an all staff meeting, and the

377
00:26:05,365 --> 00:26:09,125
company announces their new AI
initiative.

378
00:26:09,365 --> 00:26:13,750
Liana: And then almost
immediately, because the chat

379
00:26:13,750 --> 00:26:17,110
was not disabled, this isn't a
Zoom call, the Zoom chat

380
00:26:17,110 --> 00:26:20,550
explodes. If they're like
artists, for example, they're

381
00:26:20,550 --> 00:26:24,950
like, don't do this. The
programmers are like, We're

382
00:26:24,950 --> 00:26:27,725
like, we don't know what to use
it for. And then there are

383
00:26:27,725 --> 00:26:30,205
people, well, actually, truly
great. Like, and there are

384
00:26:30,205 --> 00:26:32,205
people, like, actually fighting
each other, like

385
00:26:32,525 --> 00:26:33,085
Hans Buetow: Wow.

386
00:26:33,085 --> 00:26:37,405
Liana: In a work chat. No one is
anonymous in this chat. You're

387
00:26:37,405 --> 00:26:41,500
learning for the first time,
hey, where do you stand on this?

388
00:26:41,580 --> 00:26:46,380
And that was like, oh. That was
hard to watch, actually.

389
00:26:46,380 --> 00:26:54,435
Why? It almost I mean, it's that
no religion, no politics, no AI.

390
00:26:54,595 --> 00:26:55,155
Right?

391
00:26:57,315 --> 00:27:01,715
Hans Buetow: Oh, yeah. This
feels brutal, but honestly

392
00:27:01,715 --> 00:27:07,155
correct. Your position on AI
might be seen as a signal of the

393
00:27:07,155 --> 00:27:08,275
type of person that you are.

394
00:27:08,900 --> 00:27:12,580
Liana: I think it's hard to be a
bystander. It doesn't feel that

395
00:27:12,580 --> 00:27:15,060
way when you see how quick the
chat's coming. You know what I

396
00:27:15,060 --> 00:27:15,540
mean?

397
00:27:18,020 --> 00:27:20,740
Hans Buetow: Once again, I'm
immediately having flashbacks to

398
00:27:20,740 --> 00:27:24,985
the dissolution of masking and
remote work, where the shifting

399
00:27:24,985 --> 00:27:29,865
context has made the norms into
convictions.

400
00:27:30,265 --> 00:27:33,945
Liana: You have to pick. Every
time you do something at work,

401
00:27:33,945 --> 00:27:35,625
you pick. Right?

402
00:27:35,625 --> 00:27:36,025
Hans Buetow: Yeah.

403
00:27:36,025 --> 00:27:40,600
Liana: Do I use this tool or
not? Yeah. Every every decision

404
00:27:40,600 --> 00:27:46,680
you make is what are you gonna
use for this? You either write

405
00:27:46,680 --> 00:27:51,400
your email with or without it.
You either do your PowerPoint

406
00:27:51,400 --> 00:27:52,520
with or without it.

407
00:27:53,755 --> 00:27:58,155
I already came in with my bias.
I'm like, no. I'm not. I'm not

408
00:27:58,155 --> 00:27:59,355
touching any of this.

409
00:28:03,275 --> 00:28:06,315
Hans Buetow: So Liana has been
acting on her objections. She

410
00:28:06,315 --> 00:28:09,480
tries to show colleagues how to
do pivot tables, how to do

411
00:28:09,480 --> 00:28:12,760
formulas in Excel instead of
running AI. She copy edits her

412
00:28:12,760 --> 00:28:15,880
own writing, and she's getting
noticed for it.

413
00:28:15,960 --> 00:28:19,640
Liana: It got written in my
yearly review. Lists one to two

414
00:28:19,640 --> 00:28:23,735
opportunities for the employee
to develop in their role, And

415
00:28:23,735 --> 00:28:29,175
then included in that section
was they at utilization portion.

416
00:28:29,255 --> 00:28:32,375
You should use this more. And
I'm like, okay.

417
00:28:32,695 --> 00:28:36,055
Hans Buetow: Yeah. How did that
feel to to read slash talk to

418
00:28:36,055 --> 00:28:36,935
your supervisor about?

419
00:28:37,830 --> 00:28:41,510
Liana: I had a feeling it was
going to happen.

420
00:28:41,590 --> 00:28:42,710
Hans Buetow: Okay. Why?

421
00:28:42,950 --> 00:28:46,150
Liana: Because we've already
talked about it. One of our

422
00:28:46,150 --> 00:28:51,750
employees who is relatively pro
AI is like, hey, I found a way

423
00:28:51,750 --> 00:28:56,785
to ask it about data in Excel
sheet. And I'm like, you know

424
00:28:56,785 --> 00:28:59,745
there's a formula for that,
right? Like, you don't have to

425
00:28:59,745 --> 00:29:05,905
use AI for this. And then on the
side, my supervisor is, hey, we

426
00:29:05,905 --> 00:29:07,585
can't stop people from using AI.

427
00:29:07,910 --> 00:29:13,830
You shouldn't stop people or
dissuade them from using AI.

428
00:29:14,390 --> 00:29:16,550
Hans Buetow: What do you think
it means that it got put in your

429
00:29:16,550 --> 00:29:21,270
performance review and is a part
of your growth opportunity? What

430
00:29:21,270 --> 00:29:21,750
does that mean?

431
00:29:25,255 --> 00:29:32,055
Liana: If I'm being pessimistic
about it, it means that they can

432
00:29:32,055 --> 00:29:35,415
write me up for it in the future
is what I keep thinking about.

433
00:29:36,135 --> 00:29:41,200
So I'm waiting in October to
basically be like, hey, you

434
00:29:41,200 --> 00:29:44,080
didn't do this. Like, it's a
goal and then they're gonna say

435
00:29:44,080 --> 00:29:45,120
I didn't meet it.

436
00:29:45,920 --> 00:29:48,320
Hans Buetow: Why are you are you
not meeting it?

437
00:29:48,720 --> 00:29:50,320
Liana: No. I'm not meeting it.

438
00:29:50,320 --> 00:29:51,760
Hans Buetow: I'm Are not you
going to meet it? Are you like

439
00:29:51,760 --> 00:29:52,720
purposely not meeting it?

440
00:29:52,965 --> 00:29:54,725
Liana: I wanna see what they do.

441
00:29:55,925 --> 00:29:56,725
Hans Buetow: Wow.

442
00:29:56,725 --> 00:30:00,725
Liana: I'm going to see what
happens if this is genuinely

443
00:30:00,725 --> 00:30:04,725
something that they're tracking.
Because as far as I know,

444
00:30:04,725 --> 00:30:06,805
there's nothing tracking our
usage.

445
00:30:12,680 --> 00:30:15,480
Hans Buetow: Everyone I talked
to said very clearly that work

446
00:30:15,480 --> 00:30:19,800
has a different feeling from
even a year ago. I mean, back in

447
00:30:19,800 --> 00:30:23,855
those halcyon days of 2025 or,
you know, dare we even remember

448
00:30:23,855 --> 00:30:29,215
2024, generative AI was still
enough of a novelty that

449
00:30:29,215 --> 00:30:31,855
companies didn't need to have
enterprise level solutions to

450
00:30:31,855 --> 00:30:37,260
it. Its use was, at least for
workers, early adopters who had

451
00:30:37,260 --> 00:30:40,380
personal accounts, like a Claude
account or a ChatGPT account,

452
00:30:40,380 --> 00:30:44,700
and they would use them
sometimes for work. So what has

453
00:30:44,700 --> 00:30:48,380
changed in the last year? I
think there's a case to be made

454
00:30:48,735 --> 00:30:52,575
that in this past year,
companies realized how much of

455
00:30:52,575 --> 00:30:56,895
their proprietary information
was being fed into these random

456
00:30:56,895 --> 00:30:59,455
personal AI accounts of these
employees.

457
00:30:59,935 --> 00:31:04,250
No agreement, no policy, and
definitely no oversight of where

458
00:31:04,250 --> 00:31:08,730
that data was going. And I think
it's likely that employers

459
00:31:08,730 --> 00:31:12,730
started to get nervous. And I
know that it's likely that the

460
00:31:12,730 --> 00:31:16,305
AI companies who were all
desperate for adoption, they

461
00:31:16,305 --> 00:31:20,545
were more than happy to provide
enterprise level solutions for

462
00:31:20,545 --> 00:31:25,745
that nervousness. And then what
I guess is that the c suite

463
00:31:25,745 --> 00:31:28,305
suddenly had something to be
bullish on. Right?

464
00:31:28,305 --> 00:31:32,600
Despite them probably not fully
understanding the why of it,

465
00:31:32,600 --> 00:31:37,400
just the impulse for it. And you
wrap all that up in these claims

466
00:31:37,400 --> 00:31:42,840
of efficiency and cost despite
AI being neither efficient nor

467
00:31:42,840 --> 00:31:48,225
cheap. And now here, workers are
at with each other. Some are

468
00:31:48,225 --> 00:31:51,825
exhausted and resigned and
wondering what the hell

469
00:31:51,825 --> 00:31:52,465
happened.

470
00:31:52,865 --> 00:31:56,465
Liana: I wonder if it would be
easier if it was required. Like,

471
00:31:56,465 --> 00:32:00,510
this is required. We are
measuring you. Yeah. It you're

472
00:32:00,510 --> 00:32:02,190
doing this whether we want to or
not.

473
00:32:02,190 --> 00:32:04,910
I wonder if that's I wonder if
that's easier. I'm

474
00:32:04,910 --> 00:32:06,510
Hans Buetow: not sure. In what
way?

475
00:32:06,510 --> 00:32:09,870
Liana: Because then you can sort
of offload it and be like, I'm

476
00:32:09,870 --> 00:32:15,185
only doing this because it pays
my rent versus we still get to

477
00:32:15,185 --> 00:32:20,305
pick and that gives you a lot of
ownership still. It still feels

478
00:32:20,305 --> 00:32:20,785
personal.

479
00:32:28,600 --> 00:32:33,560
Hans Buetow: Personal ownership
or paying rent. Is that really

480
00:32:33,560 --> 00:32:39,240
the best duality available to
the workers of the world? I

481
00:32:39,240 --> 00:32:46,845
slowly took off my eye bobs at
this point and rubbed my face. I

482
00:32:47,005 --> 00:32:49,885
needed to get in touch with
somebody who knew something

483
00:32:50,445 --> 00:32:54,365
about gathering together, about
working as a team, about

484
00:32:54,765 --> 00:33:00,140
solidarity. Someone familiar, a
voice in the wilderness.

485
00:33:00,380 --> 00:33:04,700
Alex Hanna: My name is doctor
Alex Hanna. I am director of

486
00:33:04,700 --> 00:33:08,965
research for the Distributed AI
Research Institute. I'm a

487
00:33:08,965 --> 00:33:14,085
sociologist and writer on
technology, labor, and politics.

488
00:33:14,965 --> 00:33:18,565
Hans Buetow: And you ran the
webinar that I that kicked all

489
00:33:18,565 --> 00:33:19,845
this off for me.

490
00:33:20,005 --> 00:33:21,605
Alex Hanna: Oh, no. Sorry about
that.

491
00:33:21,605 --> 00:33:24,920
Hans Buetow: Oh, it was a dull
it's been a delightful journey,

492
00:33:25,080 --> 00:33:29,240
and I have some questions about
kinda where I've gotten to, if

493
00:33:29,240 --> 00:33:29,960
that's okay.

494
00:33:30,120 --> 00:33:30,840
Alex Hanna: Mhmm.

495
00:33:31,480 --> 00:33:33,400
Hans Buetow: It was at this
moment right here that

496
00:33:33,400 --> 00:33:37,825
simultaneously both Alex and I
whipped out our Breakfast at

497
00:33:37,825 --> 00:33:41,585
Tiffany sunglasses, slammed them
onto our respective perfectly

498
00:33:41,585 --> 00:33:46,705
lit intensely focused visages.
So if you're a worker

499
00:33:46,945 --> 00:33:47,265
Alex Hanna: Mhmm.

500
00:33:47,265 --> 00:33:50,065
Hans Buetow: How do folks who
are in that worker class better

501
00:33:50,305 --> 00:33:55,360
understand their own agency?
Because it does feel like agency

502
00:33:55,360 --> 00:33:57,760
is a word that's at the center
of what we're we're talking

503
00:33:57,760 --> 00:34:02,400
about here. Yeah. Because Dare
has done so much work with folks

504
00:34:02,400 --> 00:34:10,025
who are organizing organizing
specifically around AI. How does

505
00:34:10,425 --> 00:34:13,785
solidarity and organizing, which
I know are not quite the same

506
00:34:13,785 --> 00:34:14,985
thing Mhmm.

507
00:34:14,985 --> 00:34:19,380
How do those intersect with AI
being imposed at work so much

508
00:34:19,380 --> 00:34:19,940
more?

509
00:34:20,500 --> 00:34:23,060
Alex Hanna: Solidarity is
important in a few different

510
00:34:23,060 --> 00:34:28,180
registers. One of them is, one,
being able to refuse and say no.

511
00:34:28,740 --> 00:34:32,625
We're not going to agree that we
have to use these technologies

512
00:34:32,865 --> 00:34:35,425
and we're not competing we
wouldn't have to compete against

513
00:34:35,425 --> 00:34:41,025
each other. Hard to do that
alone. And so the first thing is

514
00:34:41,025 --> 00:34:46,220
refusal and being able to
control where and when the

515
00:34:46,220 --> 00:34:47,740
technologies are deployed.

516
00:34:47,980 --> 00:34:51,180
So that's one element of it.
Another element of it is cross

517
00:34:51,180 --> 00:34:54,780
national solidarity. Maybe
somebody is working with the

518
00:34:54,780 --> 00:35:00,535
outputs of an LLM, but those
outputs are not coming out of

519
00:35:00,535 --> 00:35:04,455
the ether. There's a lot of
guidance or input that has been

520
00:35:04,455 --> 00:35:08,695
provided by data workers. Those
data workers are often not in

521
00:35:08,695 --> 00:35:12,730
the same workplace, they're
either in a country that's far

522
00:35:12,730 --> 00:35:17,130
away or they are folks that are
receiving a fraction of what the

523
00:35:17,130 --> 00:35:20,730
going wage is in a western
company.

524
00:35:20,810 --> 00:35:25,425
And so solidarity would look
like building alliances across

525
00:35:25,425 --> 00:35:28,225
different job classes. And so
we've seen tech workers advocate

526
00:35:28,225 --> 00:35:33,745
for data workers to folks in
Kenya being paid $2 an hour. So

527
00:35:33,745 --> 00:35:37,630
that's also very, very important
element of that. And I'd say

528
00:35:37,630 --> 00:35:41,070
that there's also a solidaristic
element that comes from

529
00:35:41,950 --> 00:35:46,670
understanding that the nature of
one's work is more than just

530
00:35:46,670 --> 00:35:50,910
one's tasks on paper. It's also
like a cross racial, cross

531
00:35:50,910 --> 00:35:52,270
gender solidarity.

532
00:35:52,270 --> 00:35:56,485
I mean, it's that's something
that's been a dynamic in US

533
00:35:56,485 --> 00:36:01,045
labor at its best. It also kind
of prevents this strike breaking

534
00:36:01,045 --> 00:36:05,285
or this kind of scabbing that
that we see in industrial

535
00:36:05,765 --> 00:36:10,160
actions. I mean, I'd love to see
solidarity with senior engineers

536
00:36:10,160 --> 00:36:12,720
and junior engineers. I'd love
to see job solidarity with

537
00:36:12,720 --> 00:36:16,080
engineers and administrative
assistants. Mhmm.

538
00:36:16,080 --> 00:36:19,040
And that could change the nature
of the relationship with

539
00:36:19,040 --> 00:36:24,555
technology and ensuring that
folks are understanding that

540
00:36:24,555 --> 00:36:30,155
casualization might be happening
in one area, but it could be

541
00:36:30,315 --> 00:36:34,950
coming for them next. Actually,
we're seeing a bit of a pretty

542
00:36:34,950 --> 00:36:38,310
big wake up call too with a lot
of people in the tech industry

543
00:36:38,630 --> 00:36:42,870
who were told four years to
learn how to code and now it's

544
00:36:42,870 --> 00:36:47,190
learn how to use an LLM or
you're going to be laid off. And

545
00:36:47,190 --> 00:36:49,430
I think solidarity is a huge
anecdote to that.

546
00:36:51,605 --> 00:36:53,845
Hans Buetow: I want to put one
more to you and see if it makes

547
00:36:53,845 --> 00:36:58,245
sense that I've been musing on.
Is it if part of the the weird

548
00:36:58,245 --> 00:37:01,765
moment where we don't have these
social norms yet between all of

549
00:37:01,765 --> 00:37:05,810
the the ways that we're
functioning because we're just

550
00:37:05,810 --> 00:37:08,930
kind of like, I I am I the only
one who's being left out? Am I

551
00:37:08,930 --> 00:37:11,650
the only one not doing this? It
seems to me that solidarity can

552
00:37:11,650 --> 00:37:16,930
also help change the perception
that everyone else is using it.

553
00:37:16,930 --> 00:37:18,850
Change the perception that I'm
gonna miss out.

554
00:37:19,055 --> 00:37:22,415
Change the perception that I'm
at risk if I don't. Because

555
00:37:22,415 --> 00:37:24,575
suddenly you're able to talk,
you're able to communicate, and

556
00:37:24,575 --> 00:37:26,895
you're able to be like, wait, do
you use it? Do you want to use

557
00:37:26,895 --> 00:37:29,615
it? You can have those
conversations in an open way in

558
00:37:29,615 --> 00:37:32,575
a way that it doesn't feel like
we have mechanisms or is even

559
00:37:32,575 --> 00:37:35,190
really appropriate in a lot of
these workplaces now.

560
00:37:35,670 --> 00:37:40,310
Alex Hanna: Yeah. No. A 100%. I
I completely agree with that. If

561
00:37:40,310 --> 00:37:45,110
there are peer groups that are
doing x y and z because there's

562
00:37:45,110 --> 00:37:47,565
not really you don't really know
what's happening, then it can

563
00:37:47,565 --> 00:37:49,165
provide a little bit more
insight.

564
00:37:49,165 --> 00:37:52,525
I mean, that's one of the
reasons we do our podcasts,

565
00:37:53,645 --> 00:37:57,165
write our book is because it is
showing that there is kind of

566
00:37:57,165 --> 00:38:02,540
another way another way to act
and be in relationship with

567
00:38:02,540 --> 00:38:06,060
these technologies that doesn't
require you to think that you

568
00:38:06,060 --> 00:38:10,380
have to use them or that one
must go on in the kind of

569
00:38:10,380 --> 00:38:14,855
technological future that you
don't have as much control over

570
00:38:14,855 --> 00:38:19,255
as you'd like to or that could
be actually empowering.

571
00:38:23,415 --> 00:38:25,655
Hans Buetow: Alex, amazing.
That's incredible. Thank you for

572
00:38:25,655 --> 00:38:29,570
that. That's that's actually a
really encouraging way to look

573
00:38:29,570 --> 00:38:31,810
at it. Great.

574
00:38:32,290 --> 00:38:33,170
I'm glad.

575
00:38:33,330 --> 00:38:33,890
Alex Hanna: I'm glad.

576
00:38:39,025 --> 00:38:41,825
Hans Buetow: Let's be clear.
Forced adoption of AI is not

577
00:38:41,825 --> 00:38:45,985
happening in every workplace,
but it clearly is happening. And

578
00:38:45,985 --> 00:38:50,545
when it's happening or it's even
being explored, AI is changing

579
00:38:50,545 --> 00:38:54,950
our workplaces and quickly. And
it's way more complicated than

580
00:38:54,950 --> 00:38:58,950
the machines will take our jobs.
There's a moral and a practical

581
00:38:58,950 --> 00:39:02,310
balance that has to be made on
an individual level.

582
00:39:02,310 --> 00:39:06,710
What does it mean to align your
values and your actions around

583
00:39:06,710 --> 00:39:11,985
this particular set of
technologies in a work context.

584
00:39:12,625 --> 00:39:18,065
There's also power to be found
in communicating and working on

585
00:39:18,065 --> 00:39:23,820
a collective level. So I think
at the end of all this, despite

586
00:39:23,820 --> 00:39:28,700
all my fears, despite my
apprehensions, what I have is

587
00:39:28,940 --> 00:39:33,900
two doctors, Alex and Casey,
each independently telling me

588
00:39:33,900 --> 00:39:39,415
that there are multiple ways
forward, even when the boss says

589
00:39:40,055 --> 00:39:55,880
there's only one. Thank you.
Thank you.

590
00:39:55,960 --> 00:39:58,840
Thank you. Thank you. You. Thank
you. Thank you to everyone who

591
00:39:58,840 --> 00:40:03,960
sent us a note, or a voice memo,
or read something for us.

592
00:40:04,895 --> 00:40:08,575
Thank you also to doctors Alex
Hanna and Casey Fiegler. We're

593
00:40:08,575 --> 00:40:10,895
gonna put links to both of their
work in the show notes, but

594
00:40:10,895 --> 00:40:14,015
we're also gonna link the
Luddite Lab, which is the

595
00:40:14,015 --> 00:40:17,055
resource that I was watching the
webinar on. It's this amazing

596
00:40:17,055 --> 00:40:21,210
thing, and it's made by DARE for
organizing at work around issues

597
00:40:21,210 --> 00:40:25,530
of AI. So if you are interested
in hearing about how others have

598
00:40:25,530 --> 00:40:29,690
done it, go and read the case
studies and check out their

599
00:40:29,690 --> 00:40:31,370
resources. It's really
interesting.

600
00:40:31,895 --> 00:40:37,415
It's really powerful and really
useful. We are gonna keep

601
00:40:37,415 --> 00:40:40,375
looking into AI in the
workplace. So if you are a

602
00:40:40,375 --> 00:40:45,850
person who is wrangling, was
wrangling, or maybe has never

603
00:40:46,250 --> 00:40:50,250
wrangled with AI in the
workplace, send us, please, your

604
00:40:50,250 --> 00:40:54,010
moral quandaries or if it's the
case, your smooth moral

605
00:40:54,010 --> 00:40:58,250
certitudes. Whatever you feel,
we wanna know. Especially if

606
00:40:58,250 --> 00:41:03,345
what you feel is that the
definitions of what AI actually

607
00:41:03,345 --> 00:41:07,025
does get misunderstood in your
workplace.

608
00:41:09,025 --> 00:41:12,385
You can find all the ways to get
in touch with us in the show

609
00:41:12,385 --> 00:41:12,705
notes.

610
00:41:52,530 --> 00:41:55,570
Mike Rugnetta: That is the show
we have for you this week. We

611
00:41:55,570 --> 00:41:59,435
are gonna be back here in the
main feed on or around Thursday,

612
00:41:59,595 --> 00:42:04,475
August 13, the week after which
is our member drive stream week,

613
00:42:04,475 --> 00:42:08,395
during which we will unveil new
merch, play new games, host new

614
00:42:08,395 --> 00:42:12,235
guests, and hopefully add to our
proud ranks a few new members

615
00:42:12,235 --> 00:42:15,520
who get access to additional
episodes, an ad free feed of the

616
00:42:15,520 --> 00:42:19,440
show, and other fun things. Do
you wanna become a member? Do

617
00:42:19,440 --> 00:42:23,920
you want a deal, a steal, a
reward for listening this far

618
00:42:23,920 --> 00:42:26,400
into the episode? You can click
the link in the show notes, the

619
00:42:26,400 --> 00:42:28,480
one all the way down at the
bottom.

620
00:42:28,480 --> 00:42:32,115
Skip that first link. Skip all
the other links all the way down

621
00:42:32,115 --> 00:42:34,755
there. At the very end, you will
find a link to a membership

622
00:42:34,755 --> 00:42:39,795
discount that will run until
stream week begins. You can

623
00:42:39,795 --> 00:42:44,515
become a member for half off a
yearly membership. That's right.

624
00:42:44,515 --> 00:42:48,660
$24 for one year of Never Post.
They're calling it the greatest

625
00:42:48,660 --> 00:42:52,420
deal in podcasting. Become a
member today at neverpo.st,

626
00:42:52,580 --> 00:42:55,060
specifically. The link all the
way at the bottom of the show

627
00:42:55,060 --> 00:42:58,900
notes. And, you know, if you're
listening to this later after

628
00:42:58,900 --> 00:43:00,475
stream week, sorry.

629
00:43:00,475 --> 00:43:02,395
You should listen to the end of
the episode. Do know we put a

630
00:43:02,395 --> 00:43:07,755
poem back here? Never Post's
producers are Audrey Evans,

631
00:43:07,755 --> 00:43:09,995
Georgia Hampton, and the
mysterious doctor first name,

632
00:43:09,995 --> 00:43:13,035
last name. Our senior producer
is Hans Buto. Our executive

633
00:43:13,035 --> 00:43:14,880
producer is Jason Oberholzer.

634
00:43:14,880 --> 00:43:24,000
The show's host, that's me, is
Mike Ragnetta. Of course, there

635
00:43:24,000 --> 00:43:28,880
are victims in this poem.
Victim. Victim. Victim.

636
00:43:28,880 --> 00:44:05,255
Victim. Victim. Excerpt of
History by Tracy k Smith. Never

637
00:44:05,255 --> 00:44:08,295
Post is a production of Charts
and Leisure, and it's

638
00:44:08,295 --> 00:44:11,110
distributed by Radiotopia.
